The thyroid, a gland in the neck, produces hormones that regulate the metabolism. It is absolutely fundamental to our body working properly. Thyroid problems can bring on various symptoms, depending on whether the thyroid is under-active or over-active.
If you have thyroid problems, some foods are worth favouring, and others worth limiting or avoiding. Today I’m going to talk to you about these foods to avoid with thyroid problems. In reality, as you’ll see, most are not “forbidden” in the strict sense of the word, but “to avoid” or “to limit”.
The recommendations in this article are to be included within an overall healthy lifestyle, for people with a thyroid dysfunction, with or without medical treatment. In no case do they replace medical treatment. Do feel free to talk this over with your doctor.
Foods to avoid with thyroid problems: what to remember:
- Adapt your diet to the type of condition: the needs differ in hypothyroidism (to stimulate) and hyperthyroidism (to slow down).
- Goitrogenic foods… it’s not all black and white.
- Iodine is to be increased in hypothyroidism (fish, seaweed) but limited in hyperthyroidism… with nuances!
- Ultra-processed products, sugars and bad fats disturb the thyroid and should be strongly reduced.
- With an auto-immune disease (Hashimoto’s, Graves’), an anti-inflammatory diet is essential.
So are there foods to avoid with thyroid problems, and if so, which ones?
I’m going to talk about:
- goitrogenic foods and soy
- iodine-rich foods
- ultra-processed products
- foods high in sugar and with a high glycaemic index
- bad fats
- pesticides, insecticides and other chemicals in food
- gluten and dairy.
1. Goitrogen-rich foods and soy: it depends on the case
In hypothyroidism
You often hear that goitrogenic foods are forbidden with hypothyroidism. In reality, you simply need to limit them. Eaten raw, they do slow the thyroid gland down by blocking the uptake of iodine. And iodine is an element the body cannot do without to make thyroid hormones. The goitrogenic foods are: all the cruciferous vegetables (the cabbage family), watercress, turnip, swede, rocket, radish, horseradish, sweet potato, millet, soybeans, rapeseed and cassava.
However: studies show that cooking largely cancels out this goitrogenic effect. And in fact, you have to eat a lot of them to get the goitrogenic effect. Which is just as well, because these foods have plenty of virtues, the cabbages in particular: they are anti-inflammatory, support the liver’s work, counter oestrogen dominance, are full of antioxidants and help a healthy microbiome. So it all depends on your iodine status.
Soy, for its part, is said to have goitrogenic effects only in the case of iodine deficiency together with a thyroid problem. It blocks the activity of TPO (the enzyme needed to make the T4 hormone). That said, some studies suggest that soy-based foods, by inhibiting iodine absorption, can increase the dose of thyroid hormone that people with hypothyroidism need. So this means testing iodine regularly. Note that in some people with the auto-immune diseases Hashimoto’s or Graves’, soy is to be avoided. I’d encourage you to see the effect soy has on you, and to cut down if needed.
As a source of soy (if you eat it), I recommend lacto-fermented tofu-based foods, or miso, and even so limiting it to twice a week. I must tell you, in a future article, about phyto-oestrogens and about relative oestrogen excess (one of the factors in hypothyroidism).
So, to sum up, a moderate intake of goitrogenic foods (apart from soy) would be acceptable for people with hypothyroidism (for example once a week raw, and 2 to 3 times a week gently steamed). I’d encourage you to listen to how you feel depending on how much you eat.
In hyperthyroidism
Here, by contrast, eating goitrogenic foods, preferably raw, will slow down an over-active thyroid, which would be beneficial. As I said above, the cruciferous vegetables in particular are really valuable on many fronts. Take kale, for example: as well as having this braking action on the butterfly gland, it brings plenty of well-absorbed calcium (good in hyperthyroidism, which lowers bone density), and it has an anti-proliferative action. More generally, for hyperthyroidism, I point you to other natural ways to support the body in the article Natural tips for hyperthyroidism.
2. Iodine-rich foods… that depends too
Iodine is an element the body cannot do without to make thyroid hormones. To build the T4 hormone, from which the active T3 hormone will follow (if all goes well), iodine is one of the main ingredients.
In hypothyroidism
So to look after your thyroid, and in hypothyroidism, your diet needs to provide iodine. Yet more than 50% of French people are thought to be deficient. If you no longer have a thyroid, iodine is still needed for other body functions, but no longer for thyroid function.
Iodine is found in the following foods: sea fish, shellfish, seaweed (watch the source, to avoid heavy metals), eggs and dairy. Table salt enriched with iodine is not ideal, as it is refined and contains additives; salt should in any case be used in moderation, and be unrefined, because of the risks to the heart and blood vessels, of oedema, and of its acidifying effect. Iodine is very volatile, though, so if the salt cellar is left open, or during cooking (of fish, for example), a good part of the iodine will have gone.
Worth knowing too: iodine levels drop with smoking and with intensive exercise.
For good thyroid function, you would want to get 150µg a day of iodine according to the guidelines (be careful about over-consuming iodine in Hashimoto’s and hyperthyroidism), whereas French people’s current intake is more like half that. Note that opinions on iodine differ (I’m thinking in particular of Dr Reliquet’s book), and it is hard to generalise. With hypothyroidism, you can eat 5g of dried seaweed flakes, or 30g rehydrated and uncooked. You’ll find them in health-food shops: dulse, wakame, sea spaghetti, sea lettuce, and nori, which contains less. Kombu seaweed contains a lot, and needs to be cooked (so some of it will evaporate).
Seaweed not your thing? I recommend trying seaweed tartare! Very easy to make yourself, or to buy in a health-food shop.
Seaweed is to be eaten about twice a week, given that it also, sadly, concentrates heavy metals, and that although you need a minimum level of iodine, an excess is not desirable for the thyroid either.
In hyperthyroidism
Conversely, in hyperthyroidism (apart from Graves’ disease), limiting iodine intake is generally advised, so iodised salt, sea fish, seaweed and dairy. You would therefore favour freshwater fish.
In the case of Graves’ auto-immune disease, studies have shown that a good many people were in fact deficient in iodine. So in these cases, I would recommend instead having your iodine status checked before limiting any iodine intake. Generally speaking, large iodine intakes (supplements, or seaweed for example) call for a sound oxidative balance, including enough selenium.
In all cases, generally speaking, with thyroid conditions it is recommended to test your iodine status (in a 24-hour urine sample) regularly.
3. Ultra-processed products, to avoid with thyroid problems
Among the various reasons why ultra-processed foods should be forbidden, or else strongly limited, with thyroid problems, we can name:
- they often contain food additives,
- they also very often have a high glycaemic index,
- they are not natural,
- they are generally high in bad fats,
- they are often very / too salty.
All of this affects thyroid function (not to mention the rest).
So avoid: packets with a never-ending list of ingredients, in particular ingredients you couldn’t buy yourself: some frozen foods, tinned foods, savoury snacks, fizzy drinks… but also foods that seem healthy and are in fact an assembly of ingredients and additives, not natural at all.
4. Foods high in sugar and with a high glycaemic index
High-glycaemic-index sugars are the ones that make blood sugar rise too quickly. These, and too much sugar in general, increase inflammation and disturb the making of thyroid hormones. Refined sugars (= white sugar, white grains) wear the body out. Our body needs vitamins and minerals to work, yet refined foods are stripped of them, so our body has to draw on its reserves.
According to Dr Claeys, this excess leads in particular to a depletion of the T3 hormone. And T3 is in charge of turning sugar into fat.
What’s more, they encourage excess weight, cardiovascular disease and metabolic syndrome, which are often part of the clinical picture in hypothyroidism.
Careful, just because an over-active thyroid produces too much T3, that doesn’t mean you should eat lots of sugar to bring it down! Sugar is still acidifying and inflammatory, and excesses are to be avoided in general, or kept to special occasions.
This means:
- any added sugar (if you are going to add a little sugar, I’d encourage you to favour whole, unrefined sugar),
- white sugar in home cooking,
- white grains (for bread, pasta, rice),
- and all sweet excesses (including excesses of whole sugar and of fruit),
So is all sugar forbidden with thyroid problems? No, we need it, but favour the semi-wholegrain or wholegrain versions, if your gut tolerates them of course. You can also usefully swap them for quinoa, tubers (squash for example) and buckwheat. Note that oats will be beneficial in hypothyroidism.
5. Bad fats
I’d urge you to read the labels of the products you buy carefully. In processed, and above all ultra-processed, products you might find “trans” or “partially hydrogenated” or “hydrogenated” fatty acids. Several studies have shown they are linked to a number of chronic diseases such as thyroid diseases, cardiovascular and heart troubles, diabetes and so on. These, then, are “forbidden”.
In the same way, too many saturated fatty acids are pro-inflammatory and stiffen cell membranes, which can then no longer work at their best. Saturated fatty acids are found mainly in meat and dairy, and in fried and breaded products. Pastries contain a good dose too. Too many omega-6s (sunflower, corn and grapeseed oils, grain-fed animals, nuts and seeds – except walnuts) is not desirable either, compared with omega-3s. They too encourage inflammation. I do mean “too many”, that is, we need these fatty acids, but without excess.
For the thyroid to work well, count on omega-3s, which you’ll find in small oily fish in particular, and in plant oils such as flax, walnut and camelina.
Note that Brazil nuts bring selenium, and eating 2 a day in hypothyroidism is recommended.
6. Pesticides and insecticides in food
Without going into detail here, just know that these are endocrine disruptors. They therefore disturb the body’s hormonal workings, and so those of the thyroid. Better, then, to eat organic, natural foods. As fat holds on to toxins, oils should be chosen organic… but this holds for plant and animal products alike.
7. Gluten and dairy: foods to avoid in Hashimoto’s and Graves’ thyroiditis
I’ve kept these last two for the end… because oh, how hard it is to go without gluten and without dairy for most of us!
The explanation:
Hashimoto’s hypothyroidism and Graves’ hyperthyroidism are auto-immune in origin, which also calls for a rethink of your diet. You can have one of these diseases, or both Hashimoto’s and Graves’. In these cases, dairy (via casein) and gluten are even more involved in inflammation. Because of various factors, people with an auto-immune disease have a “leaky” gut. So gliadin (the protein in gluten) and casein (in dairy), both pro-inflammatory, end up in the bloodstream. The body makes antibodies to counter these molecules it does not recognise.
Significantly raised levels of anti-gluten antibodies have been found in people with Hashimoto’s disease. According to Dr Gimbert, this is thought to be down to the deceptive resemblance between gliadin and the proteins of thyroid tissue. Indeed, a gluten-free diet noticeably improves the health of people with an auto-immune disease, and Hashimoto’s hypothyroidism in particular. In parallel, and for the same reasons, animal milk (cow’s above all, but also sheep’s and goat’s) also encourages auto-immune diseases, because of casein. It tends to worsen a leaky gut and to affect the immune system.
So what do you do?
In both these cases, cutting out gluten and dairy (for at least several months) is needed, to see the effects. Doing this double elimination at the same time isn’t advised, as it’s too hard. Better to start with one, then the other (unless you’re ultra-motivated!).
Dairy is found in animal milks (cow / sheep / goat), milk powder, yoghurts, cheese, crème fraîche, butter, and all the dairy hidden in many industrial preparations (milk powder and so on) such as cakes, some industrial organic breads, and so on.
Gluten is found in the following grains: rye, oats (except those labelled “gluten-free”), wheat, barley, spelt, einkorn and kamut. So you’ll find gluten in all products containing the grains listed above: breads, pastries, pasta, semolina and so on.
When you remove them, be careful not to create shortfalls in nutrients and micronutrients (calcium and other minerals, fibre, carbohydrates and so on). To give an example, industrial gluten-free sliced bread, even organic, being ultra-processed, is far from the ideal solution. So you need to work out how to replace them (calcium, for example, is found in plenty of other foods), or rather, it’s about rethinking the way you eat as a whole. You can get support so as to be sure you don’t end up deficient, and to keep your motivation going with healthy, easy and still delicious recipes.
In conclusion, which foods should you avoid with thyroid problems?
- Ultra-processed and trans-fat foods are forbidden with thyroid problems, or at the very least to be strongly limited.
- Foods that are too sugary (and high glycaemic index), and those with too much saturated fat or omega-6, are to be limited.
- Non-organic foods are to be limited too.
- In the case of auto-immune thyroid diseases, Hashimoto’s and Graves’, it is recommended to rethink your diet as well: cut out gluten and dairy products (not just any old way, at the risk of ending up deficient).
- As for foods that are sources of iodine, they are to be limited in hyperthyroidism, but on the contrary brought in with hypothyroidism.
- Conversely, goitrogenic foods are to be brought in with hyperthyroidism and limited (and gently steamed) with hypothyroidism.
I hope these tips have been useful, and that the explanations given will help you with your choices. If you have any questions, do feel free to get in touch.
Sources:
- Dr Claeys’ book “En finir avec l’hypothyroïdie”
- Dr Gimbert’s book “Thyroïde, arrêtons le massacre”
- E. M. Osansky’s book “Natural Treatment Solutions for Hyperthyroidism and Graves’ Disease”
- I. Wentz’s book “Hashimoto’s Thyroiditis – Root Cause”
- Dr Reliquet’s book “Les pouvoirs de l’iode”
- The role of micronutrients in thyroid dysfunction – PubMed (nih.gov) – Sudan J Paediatr. 2020; doi: 10.24911/SJP.106-1587138942
- Effects of soy protein and soybean isoflavones on thyroid function in healthy adults and hypothyroid patients: a review of the relevant literature – PubMed (nih.gov) – Mark Messina, Geoffrey Redmond; doi: 10.1089/thy.2006.16.249
FAQ
Are some foods really forbidden with thyroid problems?
Should I avoid goitrogenic foods like cabbage?
How much iodine do I need?
Why cut gluten and dairy with Hashimoto's or Graves'?
I am Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath based in Paris and working by video call. I am a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie and I teach at a school of naturopathy. I help people find their physical and emotional balance again through naturopathic techniques (diet, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants and so on).
Through this blog I share, in a down-to-earth way, the knowledge and experience I find useful, to help you feel better.
This advice is not a substitute for seeing your own healthcare professional, and should never keep you from doing so.