Food supplements: necessary or pointless?

Want the answer straight away? These food supplements are neither systematically necessary, nor completely pointless. It all depends on YOU: your diet, your age, your lifestyle and your specific needs. Only 12% of French people consider themselves in good health, which explains why we look for solutions.

Let’s look together at when they’re genuinely justified. At the end, I also explain why, many times, a certain number of supplements can be necessary.

 

Useful or pointless, food supplements? 6 key points to remember

  • Supplements are useful in the case of an identified deficiency or specific needs.
  • A varied, balanced diet remains the basis; supplements only… complement. Yes, in an ideal world (no stress, no nutrient-depleted soils…)
  • Some groups (pregnant women, seniors, vegetarians) have particular needs that justify supplementation…. but others do too.
  • Product quality varies enormously; not all are equal on the market.
  • Professional support helps avoid costly, ineffective or even contraindicated mistakes.
  • Sometimes a number of them are necessary at the same time (I explain why).

 

Food supplements, necessary or pointless: what are they?

number of capsules, food supplements necessary or pointless

Before knowing whether they’re necessary or pointless, let’s define food supplements: they’re concentrates of nutrients sold in dose form (capsules, ampoules…) to supplement the diet. They aren’t medicines and don’t treat anything. In other words, unlike medicines, they can’t claim any therapeutic effect.

The official definition / the legal framework:

Food supplements are “foodstuffs whose purpose is to supplement the normal diet“, according to the Ministry of Agriculture.📍

My experience as a naturopath

I’d love to be able to tell you “diet is enough”, but sadly…. And conversely, a few months ago a client (whom I was seeing for the first time) brought me the 23 supplements he’d bought for his hyperthyroidism. I reminded him that a food supplement complements, it never replaces a medicine prescribed by your doctor. And then, following the naturopathic assessment, I sorted through all of it.

Modern diet: where are the deficiencies?

A worrying nutritional picture

In France, 70% of adults have an insufficient intake of vitamin D, and 6.5% even have an outright deficiency according to ANSES. And I’m not even talking about the figures if we aim for the optimal values recommended by some doctors in functional medicine.

We also see frequent shortfalls, for example in vitamin B9, B12, iron, iodine.

Nutrient Population particularly at risk Example consequences
Vitamin D 70% of adults Bone fragility, weakened immunity
Iron 25% of women Anaemia, chronic tiredness
Magnesium 45% of the population Stress, sleep problems
Vitamin B12 Vegetarians/vegans Anaemia, neurological problems
Iodine Regions far from the sea Thyroid dysfunction

vitamin B12 vegan food supplements necessary or pointless

The factors behind modern depletion

Depleted soils = emptied foods. Today’s fruit and vegetables are said to contain 90% fewer nutrients than 50 years ago, according to Conscious Planet. An orange from 1950 had 5 to 10 times more vitamin C than one today.

Here are the factors depleting our diet nowadays:

  • Over-exploitation of soils, intensive use of chemical fertilisers, no crop rotation, premature harvesting and long-distance transport,
  • Chronic stress increasing our magnesium needs,
  • Air pollution requiring more antioxidants
  • Industrial processing destroying vitamins and minerals
  • Excessive cooking eliminating up to a certain % of vitamins
  • Taking certain medications (e.g. statins are thought to lower our level of co-enzyme Q10, according to the PubMed study PMID 30371340)
  • Tobacco, which lowers vitamin C reserves.
food supplements necessary or pointless, depleted soils

 

📍My observation in consultation

Most of the people I see do indeed lack iodine and vitamin D (classic naturopathic tests), and many women lack iron (even if it stays within the acceptable limit). A client recently told me: “I eat fruit and vegetables every day as recommended, 5 a day, but I’m still tired.” During our discussion, it comes out that she mainly eats produce harvested green and stored for a long time, and often cooked. The result: insufficient nutritional intake despite her efforts! (well, 5 times isn’t enough by naturopathic criteria, and quantity matters, but it also depends on her terrain). Also, tiredness can have other causes, of course.

 

A naturopathic view of imbalances

For us naturopaths, these deficiencies are only the visible part of the iceberg. We consider the body as a whole and identify several root causes:

The unbalanced terrain. An inflamed gut absorbs nutrients poorly, even when they’re present. Chronic stress literally “eats” our magnesium reserves. Oxidative pollution uses up our protective antioxidants.

Nutritional vicious circles. A magnesium deficiency generates stress, which itself increases the need for magnesium. A vitamin D deficit weakens immunity, encouraging infections and inflammation, which further deplete our reserves.

The naturopathic causal approach therefore aims to restore: for example, digestive balance for better absorption, stress management to reduce the needs, …

 

 

Who really needs supplements?

At-risk groups that justify supplementation

Food supplements, necessary or pointless? This question finds its answer in precisely identifying the at-risk groups. ANSES points out that only certain groups have real needs for supplements: pregnant women, older people, vegans (according to Consoglobe, in 2025).

  • Pregnant women: vitamin B9 (in methylfolate form to be sure it’s active) must be taken from conception to prevent neural tube defects. Iron is also often necessary (and that’s not all – that said: never supplement iron without a test first). Careful: 75% of pregnant women take supplements by self-medication, which can be dangerous without medical follow-up.
  • Seniors over 65: their digestive absorption declines, in particular for vitamin B12.

Other specific profiles:

  • Vegetarians/vegans (B12 compulsory, iron, zinc, omega-3 DHA often deficient)
  • Intensive athletes: increased needs for magnesium, B vitamins, antioxidants…
  • People on certain medications (I’ll let you look at that with your doctor / pharmacist)
  • In mainland France: no vitamin D synthesis from October to April; but also, e.g.: dark skin, which needs 20 times more exposure to synthesise it.
  • Chronic digestive problems: malabsorption of nutrients…

Signs of deficiencies to recognise: a few examples

Persistent tiredness despite enough sleep can reveal a deficiency in iron, magnesium or B vitamins. Repeated infections suggest a vitamin D or zinc deficit. Hair loss can point to a lack of iodine, iron, and others (including a lack of protein linked to hair loss).

 

📍 My approach in a naturopathic consultation

A 35-year-old client consults me for “chronic tiredness”, already taking 2 supplements (adaptogenic plants, magnesium and B vitamins (a supplement well known in pharmacies). After an assessment, it turns out she’s short of protein, and has low ferritin, linked to heavy periods (first hypothesis). A dietary readjustment and targeted supplements will be needed to address the cause of the problem.

 

 

The limits and risks to know

Careful! Food supplements, necessary or pointless, aren’t harmless: whether it’s overdoses, drug interactions, products of variable quality (better or worse forms, like marine magnesium for example)… “Natural” doesn’t mean “safe”. It would take a whole book or a thesis to list it all, but do your research well, or call on someone who knows all this.

 

 

Naturopathy: favouring diet and lifestyle

Diet is the first technique in naturopathy (then come physical activity and stress management, also essential): 95% of needs should be covered by a varied, quality plate.

But as we’ve seen, that’s without counting the current issues above (or dietary constraints, e.g.: no B12 if vegan, etc).

Absorption is also optimised in naturopathy (without it, the intake from a given food will be lower):

  • chewing (the first step of digestion),
  • stress management (which can also prevent good digestion),
  • food combining (e.g. lentils + parsley / vitamin C to better absorb non-heme iron),
  • soaking (where needed, to remove the anti-nutrients that prevent good bioavailability…).
food supplements necessary or pointless, diet

Why sometimes too many food supplements are necessary (and not pointless)

In some cases, a number of food supplements are necessary (and not pointless):

  • For the reasons already mentioned above, but also:
  • Several aims: the naturopath may want to work on the cause of the problem, but also help relieve the signs (an anti-symptomatic view, coupled with work on the root of the problem).
  • Incompatibilities between certain components, which means they can’t be in the same supplement. That’s the case, for example, with magnesium and iron, or iron and zinc, which must be taken separately otherwise there’s competition in absorption.
  • The doses needed may not fit into one capsule. For example, for real magnesium supplementation, you need around 300mg a day… What’s more, magnesium is taken in several goes, because beyond about 150mg, it isn’t stored and goes out in the urine. So you need magnesium in addition to the other supplements, and to take it in 2 goes.
  • Times of day: some supplements are better taken in the morning because they’re stimulating, others in the evening. Or: the case of many plants / or supplements, which, to be effective, are taken away from meals or 20 minutes before (so apart from the omega-3s, which are taken during the meal).

 

=> Making the selection isn’t always easy when you want to help someone as much and as quickly as possible. That said, personally, I make a point of taking the person’s budget into account as much as possible, and try to balance quality / price as much as I can.

 

FAQ

Is it really necessary to take food supplements?

No, food supplements aren’t systematically necessary. A balanced, varied diet remains the priority. However, and I’d say sadly, certain nutritional deficiencies, increased needs or absorption difficulties can justify targeted supplementation. In naturopathy, the aim is to identify your individual needs rather than pile on supplements needlessly.

Which supplements to take for chronic tiredness?

It all depends on where your tiredness comes from! A lack of iron, vitamin B12, vitamin D or magnesium can notably be involved. But tiredness can also be linked to sleep, stress or other health problems. Before any supplementation, it’s important to look for the cause.

Can you take several food supplements at the same time?

Yes, several supplements can sometimes be useful at once, in particular when several nutritional deficits are identified. However, some nutrients can compete during absorption, and interactions with medication are possible. The doses, the times of day and any contraindications (and interactions with your medication!) must therefore be checked. Piling on capsules isn’t necessarily a sign of effectiveness!

How do you know if you need food supplements in naturopathy?

An individualised assessment lets you examine your diet, your lifestyle, your symptoms, any treatments and your specific needs. The aim is to favour diet, spot any absorption problems and suggest, when it’s justified, supplementation suited to your needs and your budget.

I’m Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath in Paris and online, a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie, and a trainer at a naturopathy school. I help people regain physical and emotional balance through naturopathic techniques (nutrition, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants…).

Through this blog, I share, in an accessible way, knowledge and experiences I find useful, to help you feel better.

This advice is not a substitute for, and should not stop you from, consulting your healthcare professional.

Website and search: Jigsaw Studio