Can you have both Hashimoto’s and Graves’ disease?

Hashimoto’s and Graves’… the two autoimmune disorders of the thyroid, one causing hypothyroidism, which slows the metabolism, the other causing hyperthyroidism, which speeds it up. Hashimoto’s and Graves’ are the two most common situations in thyroid problems. It can seem paradoxical to have both, or one and then the other… and yet I see it more and more in consultation, with people who don’t understand it, so I did some digging… and I thought I’d write you an article about it. Some people have several positive thyroid antibodies, and a picture that doesn’t quite fit the classic categories. Others describe symptoms that swing: fatigue, weight gain… then, at other times, palpitations, nervousness, a feeling of everything speeding up. So the question often comes back: is it possible to have both Hashimoto’s and Graves’ at once? Because an idea is emerging more and more clearly today: autoimmune thyroid diseases may not be entirely separate entities, but different expressions of the same imbalance. In this article, I’ll show you how these forms can coexist or change over time. And next, in an upcoming article, I’ll offer you some naturopathic avenues for working on this autoimmune terrain. ⚠️ Important: Just before we start: I don’t diagnose anything at all (I’m not a doctor), and this article isn’t meant to diagnose either, nor to replace medical care. It draws both on data from the scientific literature (even if the number of cases in these studies isn’t huge) and on observations from practice, to better understand some situations that can seem puzzling.

Hashimoto’s and Graves’: truly opposite… or is it possible to have both?

Is it possible to have both Hashimoto’s AND Graves’, when on paper everything about these two disorders is opposite? In theory, it all seems fairly simple. The thyroid works as a regulator of the metabolism. When it produces too many hormones, everything speeds up. When it doesn’t produce enough, everything slows down. Within this framework, two autoimmune diseases are classically distinguished:

  • Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, linked to hypothyroidism: the immune system gradually attacks the gland, which reduces its ability to produce hormones.
  • Graves’ disease, linked to hyperthyroidism: here, the immune system over-stimulates the thyroid, leading to hormone overproduction.

These two pictures are therefore opposite, and this difference is largely explained by the type of antibodies involved. In Hashimoto’s, we most often find anti-TPO and/or anti-thyroglobulin antibodies. These antibodies take part in the inflammation and the gradual destruction of the gland. In Graves’, the TSH-receptor antibodies (TRAb) are raised, but there can also be (and quite often, in what I see at least) the anti-TPO and/or anti-TG antibodies that are present in Hashimoto’s. TRAb have a stimulating effect: they “mimic” the signal normally sent by the brain to the thyroid, and push it to produce more hormones. If we stop at this view, everything seems clear. And yet, as soon as we step outside the theoretical framework — and especially when we observe people over time — this opposition can become less clear-cut. We realise that:

  • some profiles don’t fit into a single box
  • all the antibodies can coexist
  • and the symptoms don’t always follow the expected logic.

In other words: on paper, everything looks opposite… but in reality, there are cases where it’s more nuanced.

What we see in practice

(Maybe I should say “what I see”)

Most of the time, a person has only Hashimoto’s or only Graves’. But sometimes things become more complex. In consultation, it’s not unusual to meet people who show several types of antibodies at the same time: TRAb + anti-TPO and/or anti-thyroglobulin. This is most often the case with people who have Graves’. And when the TRAb come back down, sadly that isn’t always the case for the other two antibodies.

What’s more, more rarely, I find it’s also possible for a person with Hashimoto’s to also show TRAb antibodies (Graves’) in a far from negligible quantity. Another common situation: symptoms that don’t fit neatly into a single category. Some people describe both:

  • fatigue, weight gain, feeling the cold, hair loss in both cases
  • but also palpitations, irritability, or a feeling of speeding up.

Sometimes these symptoms alternate. Sometimes they coexist. You also come across even more puzzling profiles:

  • positive antibodies (meaning: raised) with no marked signs
  • or the other way round, very present symptoms with fairly “atypical” bloodwork
  • people with hyperthyroidism… who don’t lose weight, or even gain it, … and people with hypothyroidism who lose a lot of weight…

These profiles are simply less described in the classic theoretical models.

I’m putting the screenshot below of the Google reviews taken from my account, just to show you that these situations do exist:

Google review from a client who has both Hashimoto's and Graves'

These observations can give the impression that “something doesn’t add up”, or that the situation isn’t clear. But in fact, they often reflect another way of understanding autoimmune thyroid disorders. Because rather than fixed, opposite boxes, we’re probably dealing with a more dynamic system, able to change over time and to express itself in different ways depending on the person. And this point is being explored more and more today in the scientific literature.

What the literature says

In the scientific literature, such as PubMed, we find more and more descriptions of these situations. Several publications report cases where a person moves from Graves’ hyperthyroidism to Hashimoto’s hypothyroidism, sometimes several years later (I’ve already heard people tell me they’d been told this wasn’t possible: and yet I have seen this kind of client… and I also have one in my own family). The reverse has also been described, even if it seems rarer: an autoimmune hypothyroidism that progresses towards hyperthyroidism. Here again, this kind of transition can be surprising, but it is documented. Beyond these changes over time, some studies also report forms of coexistence. In other words, people who show both:

  • antibodies characteristic of Hashimoto’s
  • and antibodies characteristic of Graves’

In these situations, one clinical picture tends to dominate, but the other component is very much present in the background. Some descriptions go even further. People sometimes talk of fluctuations between hyper- and hypothyroidism, with profiles that “swing” from one state to the other. This phenomenon, sometimes called “swinging thyroid”, remains uncommon but is described in clinical cases. I nearly forgot to mention that Hashimoto’s can begin with hyperthyroidism (or you sometimes fall back into a hyper phase), and this is well recognised. This initial phase of transient hyperthyroidism, called hashitoxicosis, is explained by the inflammatory destruction of the thyroid cells, which releases the hormones stored beforehand, before hypothyroidism gradually sets in. What we need to take away is that these different forms — progression, coexistence, fluctuations — are not simply isolated anomalies. They suggest that the border between Hashimoto’s and Graves’ is not as clear-cut as the theory makes it look.

Having both Hashimoto’s and Graves’ is possible, but look at the autoimmune side

Autoimmune attack on the thyroid: having both Hashimoto's and Graves' is possible

Across these observations and the available data, there is clearly the fact that these are two autoimmune diseases, and it is recognised that once you trigger one autoimmune disease, you are unfortunately more likely to trigger others. For example, Hashimoto’s is associated with coeliac disease, lupus, rheumatoid arthritis and others. Graves’ is associated with vitiligo, pernicious anaemia, Sjögren’s syndrome and others (I wanted to add more references but I don’t have them to hand: I’ll try to remember to add them!). Some hypotheses suggest that it could all depend on the balance between the different types of antibodies: those that stimulate the thyroid, and those that hold it back. Depending on their proportion, their activity, and the thyroid’s ability to respond, the clinical picture could then vary:

  • hyperthyroidism
  • hypothyroidism
  • mixed or fluctuating forms

These mechanisms are still fairly little explored, and every situation is unique. But I find that this reading shifts the focus towards what matters to us in naturopathy: rather than focusing only on a label (“Hashimoto’s” or “Graves'”), it makes sense to take an interest in the autoimmune terrain as a whole. This is precisely where the naturopathic approach can bring something complementary: not by replacing medical care, but by seeking to support the body’s overall balance. In the next article, we’ll look at exactly which avenues can be considered to work on this autoimmune terrain, beyond the hypo- or hyperthyroidism.

 

FAQ

Can you really have both Hashimoto's and Graves' at the same time?

Yes. They’re usually described as opposites, but in practice the two can overlap. Some people carry several types of thyroid antibodies at once (TRAb alongside anti-TPO and/or anti-thyroglobulin), and some move from one picture to the other over time. It stays uncommon, but it is documented in the literature and I do see it in consultation. Whatever the picture, staying under medical and endocrinological supervision is essential.

What is the difference between Hashimoto's and Graves'?

In Hashimoto’s, the immune system gradually attacks the thyroid, so it makes fewer hormones and the metabolism slows down (hypothyroidism), usually with anti-TPO and/or anti-thyroglobulin antibodies. In Graves’, the immune system over-stimulates the gland through TSH-receptor antibodies (TRAb), so it makes too many hormones and everything speeds up (hyperthyroidism). On paper they look opposite, but the antibodies can coexist.

Can one turn into the other over time?

It can. Several publications describe people moving from Graves’ hyperthyroidism to Hashimoto’s hypothyroidism, sometimes years later, and the reverse has been reported too, though it seems rarer. Some profiles even swing between hyper- and hypothyroidism, and Hashimoto’s can start with a short hyperthyroid phase (hashitoxicosis). These shifts can be surprising, but they are recognised.

Why look at the autoimmune terrain rather than the label?

Because both conditions come back to an immune system that is out of balance, and the thyroid is where it shows up rather than where it starts. Fixating on whether it is Hashimoto’s or Graves’ does not always help. In naturopathy I take an interest in the autoimmune terrain as a whole, to support the body’s overall balance alongside medical care, never instead of it.

I’m Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath in Paris and online, a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie, and a trainer at a naturopathy school. I help people regain physical and emotional balance through naturopathic techniques (nutrition, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants…). Through this blog, I share, in an accessible way, knowledge and experiences I find useful, to help you feel better. This advice is not a substitute for, and should not stop you from, consulting your healthcare professional.

 

Website and search: Jigsaw Studio