Protein deficiency: the signs to look out for

Protein plays a fundamental role in how the body works, and in keeping us well both physically and mentally. We often call it the building blocks of life, because it is essential to building and running our body.

Protein comes either from animals (meat and fish, for example) or from plants (lentils and the like). To keep things simple, during digestion it is broken down into amino acids (the raw materials that make up protein), which can then be put back together to build the many different proteins our body needs.

I see a lot of people in my practice who simply do not eat enough of it, sometimes because they are afraid of having too much, sometimes because they believe once a day (or less) is plenty. So in this article I will go through the possible signs of low protein, and how to put things back in balance so you feel better. I will also look at the people most likely to fall short. But first, let’s see why protein matters so much.

animal sources of protein

Why is protein so essential?

Protein is the body’s builder, whether that means building, repairing or maintaining the body’s tissues.

  1. Structure: it is the building material of muscles, bones, skin, hair, nails and the internal organs, and it gives our cells their shape. Collagen and keratin are two of these structural proteins.
  2. Metabolism and regulation: protein works at the level of our metabolism. As enzymes, proteins help regulate the body’s chemical reactions. Enzymes are the catalysts for a great many essential biochemical processes, from digestion to blood clotting. Without them, these processes would happen far too slowly.
  3. Defence: to fight off infections and pathogens, the immune system relies on specific proteins such as antibodies (which neutralise antigens, harmful foreign substances). It also makes other kinds of protein that help the body defend itself, but I will not go into the detail here.
  4. Fluid balance: some proteins, such as albumin and globulin, help keep the body’s fluids in balance (neither too much nor too little).
  5. Transport: some proteins carry essential nutrients around the body. Haemoglobin, for instance, carries oxygen and carbon dioxide wherever they are needed. When protein is low, that transport can become less efficient.
  6. Messaging, through hormones and neurotransmitters: hormones are our chemical messengers, and they are essential for regulating many of the body’s functions. Some hormones are themselves proteins (insulin, for one) and others are carried by proteins (the thyroid hormones). The faster messengers that pass nerve signals along are the neurotransmitters, made from amino acids or proteins. One example is serotonin, which the body makes from protein.
  7. A source of energy.

The signs of low protein

Here are several signs that could point to low protein. Do bear in mind that none of them is specific to protein alone, meaning the cause may be something else, and it is often down to several things at once.

  1. Lasting tiredness: one of the most common signs of low protein is feeling constantly tired and/or weak.
  2. Loss of muscle and bone: muscle is mostly made of protein, so going short can mean losing muscle mass and strength. The same goes for bone, with a greater risk of osteoporosis.
  3. Skin, hair and nails: low protein can bring on skin problems such as dryness, flaking and irritation. Hair is rich in protein too, keratin in particular, so a shortfall can mean more hair loss and poorer hair quality. Nails are sensitive to it as well. They turn more brittle and split or break more easily when protein is low.
  4. Swelling (oedema): a lack of protein can let fluid build up in the tissues, causing swelling that often shows around the eyes, hands and feet.
  5. Frequent infections: going short on protein helps weaken the immune system, which leaves the body more open to infections (recurring whitlows, or colds, for example).
  6. Slowed growth in children: in children, low protein can slow growth, affect physical and mental development, and cause longer-term problems.
  7. Slower recovery after exercise: people who train may notice they recover more slowly after exercise when they are short on protein.

Who is most likely to fall short on protein

Anyone can end up low on protein, of course. But some people are more at risk than others.

  • Vegetarians and vegans: if the diet is not well balanced (animal protein properly replaced with plant protein), vegetarians and vegans can run low on protein. Protein is either:
    • from animals: meat, fish, seafood and shellfish, eggs, dairy
    • or from plants: pulses including soya, nuts and seeds, seaweed, quinoa, to name only a few. Plant protein, though, is not always complete, meaning it does not necessarily contain all the essential amino acids (the ones the body cannot make itself). As a rule, pulses need to be paired with grains, in the same meal or over the same day, to make a complete protein, in a ratio of roughly one third to two thirds.
  • Older people: older people often need more protein because of the muscle loss that comes with age (known as sarcopenia) and the drop in nutrient absorption. On top of that, we tend to eat less protein as we get older.

 

  • Athletes and people who train hard: anyone doing intense physical activity needs more protein for muscle repair and growth, so they need to eat more of it.
an athlete, who needs more protein
  • People recovering: anyone recovering from an illness or surgery often needs more protein to support healing and recovery.

 

  • People affected by eating disorders: those living with an eating disorder such as anorexia or bulimia may not take in enough protein because of the disorder and/or the food restriction that goes with it.

 

  • Pregnant and breastfeeding women: pregnant and breastfeeding women need more protein, as it supports the baby’s growth and the production of breast milk.
a pregnant woman, who needs more protein

How to make sure you get enough protein

How much protein you need depends on several things, among them your age, how active you are, pregnancy and so on. So it really has to be worked out person by person. You can find the figures on the Anses website. In naturopathy, for a “normal” level of activity, the usual advice is to eat protein twice a day, each portion about the size of the palm of your hand.

Once you know your own protein needs, how do you meet them, given the way you eat?

If you recognise yourself among the people not getting enough, I would encourage you to think about the way that would best fit you for working more of it in. That might be:

– planning meals ahead, and buying fresh and/or frozen,

– always keeping some basics in the cupboard: pulses, grains, pseudo-grains (quinoa, buckwheat), and also small oily fish in tins such as sardines,

– cooking ahead when that is doable and still tastes good,

– having a protein top-up ready for particular situations. I have a very simple example of a client, a schoolteacher, who brought leftover soup for lunch. I suggested adding a tin of sardines, but “that was out of the question because of the smell in the staff room”. She was happy, though, to add pulses to her soup and round it off with a slice of bread. To make a complete plant protein, you pair one third pulses with two thirds grains.

For anyone who struggles, for one reason or another, to work in more protein, protein powders or protein bars (good-quality ones) can be part of a top-up, ideally a temporary one.

plant sources of protein

To sum up

Protein, then, is fundamental in our diet. It is one of the pillars of our health. Learning to spot the signs of low protein is one of the steps towards feeling well. Whether you are vegetarian, pregnant, an athlete or simply mindful of your wellbeing, listening to your body’s signals and adjusting your diet to match can make a real difference.

In any case, protein is certainly needed, but we should not forget the other macro and micronutrients along the way.

If you would like to tailor this more closely to you, do feel free to get in touch.

FAQ

How do I know if I am not getting enough protein?
There is no single tell-tale sign. The common ones are lasting tiredness, loss of muscle and strength, weaker hair and nails, more frequent infections and slow recovery after exercise. None of these points to protein on its own, so they are worth looking at alongside the rest of your diet and your lifestyle.
How much protein do I actually need?
It depends on your age, how active you are, whether you are pregnant and so on, so it is best worked out individually. As a rough naturopathic guide for a normal level of activity, two protein portions a day, each about the size of your palm, is a sensible starting point. You can find the official figures on the Anses website.
Can I get enough protein on a vegetarian or vegan diet?
Yes, with a little planning. Plant protein is not always complete on its own, so pair pulses with grains over the same meal or day, roughly one third pulses to two thirds grains, and build in a good variety of pulses, soya, nuts, seeds and quinoa.
Are protein powders and bars a good idea?
They can help as a top-up when you genuinely struggle to get enough from food, ideally as a temporary measure rather than a permanent fix, and choosing good-quality ones. Whole foods first, supplements to fill the gap.
Céline Jablonski naturopath

I am Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath based in Paris and working by video call. I am a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie and I teach at a school of naturopathy. I help people find their physical and emotional balance again through naturopathic techniques (diet, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants and so on).

Through this blog I share, in a down-to-earth way, the knowledge and experience I find useful, to help you feel better.

This advice is not a substitute for seeing your own healthcare professional, and should never keep you from doing so.

Website and search: Jigsaw Studio