Goitrogenic vegetables and the thyroid

The question of goitrogenic vegetables comes up often among people with thyroid problems. Should you avoid them completely or can you eat them without worry? What about with hypothyroidism? With hyperthyroidism?

Can you eat goitrogenic vegetables with a thyroid problem?
Yes, in the vast majority of cases. Contrary to a received idea, goitrogenic vegetables (broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, kale…) generally don’t need to be cut out. Their impact depends mainly on the quantity eaten, the cooking method, your iodine status and your thyroid condition. In this article, I explain what the scientific studies say and in which cases it’s better to be more careful.

What is a goitrogenic vegetable? before we look at their impact on the thyroid

Goitrogens are natural substances present in certain foods that can interact with iodine metabolism. And iodine is an element essential to the production of thyroid hormones, and goitrogenic vegetables can “capture” it.

The main foods with goitrogenic properties are

  • Brassicas: all the cabbages, including broccoli, cauliflower, kale, but also: turnips, radishes, mustard, watercress, swede, rocket, horseradish,
  • Soya
  • Cassava, millet, sweet potatoes, rapeseed
goitrogenic vegetables and thyroid

The impact of goitrogens on the thyroid: several factors come into play

These foods could inhibit thyroid function because they can disrupt the incorporation of iodine into the thyroid gland. However, this depends on several factors:

  • The quantity eaten (e.g.: you probably don’t eat 100g of mustard per dish…, and perhaps not a glass of raw cabbage juice every single day – see below)
  • The type of vegetables eaten
  • The way they’re cooked
  • The state of the thyroid (hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, autoimmune disease…)
  • The person’s iodine status.

Does cooking reduce the goitrogenic effect?

Several studies show that cooking strongly reduces the goitrogen content. Gentle steaming destroys the goitrogenic effect a little less than prolonged boiling.

Do you have to eat large quantities to have an impact?

  • For a real effect to be seen, you’d have to eat very high quantities, and raw, of these vegetables every day, in the absence of a sufficient iodine intake.
  • A normal consumption (a few portions a week) is normally no problem at all.

A few figures, and to go further into the type of goitrogens:

In a University of California study, the researchers concluded that “the uptake of radioactive iodine by the thyroid is inhibited by 194 μmol of goitrin, but not by 77 μmol of goitrin. Green cabbage, Brussels sprouts and some Russian cabbages (Brassica napus) contain enough goitrin to potentially reduce iodine uptake by the thyroid. However, turnip tops, broccoli and curly kale belonging to Brassica oleracea contain less than 10 μmol of goitrin per 100 g portion and can be considered to present a minimal risk”.

a glass of cabbage juice, goitrogen and thyroid

There isn’t enough data available to define the quantity of cruciferous vegetable consumption needed to cause thyroid dysfunction. A study on only five healthy participants (so, implicitly: without thyroid problems) showed a 25% decrease in radioactive iodine uptake after consuming kale juice twice a day for 7 days, while the serum thyroid function tests were unchanged. Likewise, soya is said to have goitrogenic effects only in cases of iodine deficiency.

The benefits of goitrogenic vegetables

It’s all a matter of balance. Keep in mind that goitrogenic vegetables are very interesting, it would be a shame to go without them:

The cabbages (especially young broccoli shoots) are rich in sulforaphane, a powerful compound with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. Sulforaphane stimulates liver detoxification and helps prevent cancer by activating protective genes. It also regulates excess oestrogen levels. Other compounds like indole-3-carbinol (I3C) and DIM support the detoxification of these oestrogens. Cabbages also provide flavonoids like quercetin and kaempferol, which protect the heart and fight inflammation. They’re an excellent source of vitamins C and K1. Their prebiotic fibre content encourages a healthy gut microbiome. Steaming preserves their nutrients better, and adding mustard or raw radish helps activate the sulforaphane.

The sweet potato, cassava and millet, for their part, are good alternatives when eating gluten-free, and sweet potato has, in addition, a very moderate glycaemic index! In all cases, you eat them cooked!

broccoli and the benefits of goitrogenic vegetables

Hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism: should you worry?

With hypothyroidism: If the cause is an iodine deficiency, excessive and regular consumption of raw goitrogenic vegetables could make the situation worse. However, a balanced diet with a sufficient iodine intake (via food or a supplement, taken away from the consumption of goitrogens) would neutralise this effect.

seaweed and iodine for the thyroid

The special case of Hashimoto’s (autoimmune hypothyroidism): here, it’s more the inflammatory processes that are the problem, rather than the goitrogens themselves. But of course, if you lack iodine, that won’t help either. With Hashimoto’s, and Graves’ for that matter, it’s better to look after, among other things, your intestinal barrier (leaky gut). With Hashimoto’s, be careful with excess iodine too. It’s better to be supported.

With hyperthyroidism: Some suggest that goitrogens could have a beneficial effect by reducing the excess of thyroid hormones. This would come from the fact that, as seen above, there’d be a capturing of iodine. But: on one hand, a large number of people with hyperthyroidism also lack iodine (the cause of hyperthyroidism being, in 90% of cases, Graves’ disease, and not too high an iodine intake). On the other hand, as seen earlier, you’d have to eat a lot of them to benefit from this effect. So why not, it’s always a plus, if you already have a good iodine status, but otherwise, it’s better to favour other techniques to deal with hyperthyroidism. And yes, iodine isn’t only beneficial for the thyroid, but also for the proper working of the ovaries, testicles, and iodine helps reduce the risk of breast cysts and fibrosis. If you already have a low iodine status, it’s better not to lower it further.

Conclusion: can you eat goitrogenic vegetables with a thyroid problem?

Goitrogenic vegetables can be a problem for the thyroid if you eat a large quantity raw. Even with hypothyroidism, eating raw goitrogens, in moderate quantity / not every day, shouldn’t be a problem. Especially if you have a sufficient iodine intake (and no iodine deficiency). If you have a doubt, favour the gently steamed versions to reduce the goitrogenic effect, but a little raw is acceptable too. With hyperthyroidism, there’s no problem eating them.

Brassicas and other goitrogenic foods are rich in micronutrients, antioxidants and fibre. So they’re beneficial for wellbeing, as long as their consumption is reasonable and suitable.

Note that with hypothyroidism it’s worth doing a urinary iodine test regularly, to know your iodine status and be more flexible about eating goitrogens. You can also remember that goitrogenic foods are to be eaten separately from an iodine-rich meal if your iodine status is low.

 

 

FAQ

Can you eat goitrogenic vegetables when you have hypothyroidism?

Yes, eaten in reasonable quantity and preferably cooked, goitrogenic vegetables generally don’t pose a problem if you have hypothyroidism, especially if your iodine intake is sufficient.

What are the main goitrogenic vegetables?

The best known are the brassicas: broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, kale, turnip, radish, rocket, watercress, mustard and swede. Soya, millet, cassava and sweet potato also have goitrogenic properties.

Does cooking reduce the goitrogenic effect?

Yes. Cooking clearly reduces the content of goitrogenic compounds. Gentle steaming helps limit their effect while keeping much of their nutritional quality.

Are goitrogenic vegetables bad for the thyroid?

No, you shouldn’t demonise goitrogenic vegetables. In most people, they’re safe and provide many antioxidants, fibre and vitamins. The risk mainly concerns a very large consumption of raw vegetables, combined with an iodine deficiency.

I’m Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath in Paris and online, a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie, and a trainer at a naturopathy school. I help people regain physical and emotional balance through naturopathic techniques (nutrition, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants…).

Through this blog, I share, in an accessible way, knowledge and experiences I find useful, to help you feel better.

This advice is not a substitute for, and should not stop you from, consulting your healthcare professional.

Website and search: Jigsaw Studio