Natural contraception

Contraception is a hugely important subject for a lot of people, whether they’re trying to avoid an unplanned pregnancy, to plan their family, or to avoid certain downsides (acne and so on). The choice of contraception depends on individual preferences, health needs and each person’s personal circumstances.

Natural contraception offers a holistic, body-respecting approach, based on understanding the menstrual cycle and the signs of fertility. (We won’t be talking here about other natural methods of a mechanical type, nor withdrawal, nor any devices.)

Here we’ll go into what natural contraception is, the different methods available, how effective they are, and the benefits and things to weigh up when taking up such an approach. Note that the naturopath’s role isn’t to steer you towards any particular form of contraception, but to inform, and to point you to your doctor if needed.

 

What is natural contraception?

Natural contraception is a non-invasive, body-respecting approach to managing fertility and avoiding or planning a pregnancy. It doesn’t use hormones (neither synthetic nor natural).

At the heart of natural contraception is knowledge of the menstrual cycle and the natural fluctuations in a woman’s fertility. Women are generally fertile during a specific part of their menstrual cycle, called the fertile window. By identifying these fertile periods and taking preventive measures during them (abstinence or protection), couples can choose to conceive or to avoid a pregnancy. Note that withdrawal is far from 100% effective.

Natural contraception methods rely on different techniques to work out a woman’s fertile periods. This can include daily monitoring of basal body temperature, observing changes in cervical mucus (I explain below), using menstrual calendars to track cycles, or a combination of these. The main aim is to identify the days when a woman is fertile and so likely to conceive, so she can make informed decisions.

Be aware, it’s important to note that natural contraception does not protect against sexually transmitted infections (STIs). It’s also not as effective as some conventional contraceptive methods.

The natural contraception methods

Here are some of the most commonly used methods:

  • The basal body temperature method: this involves taking your basal body temperature (BBT) every morning on waking. Body temperature rises slightly after ovulation, which can mark the start of the fertile window. By tracking these temperature changes, a woman can identify her fertile days and avoid unprotected sex during that time.
taking basal body temperature for natural contraception
  • The Billings method: this involves observing the changes in cervical mucus throughout the menstrual cycle. Cervical mucus is a fluid produced by the cervix. Its texture and amount vary throughout the cycle in response to hormonal fluctuations. During fertile periods, cervical mucus becomes clear, stringy and stretchy, and wetter, helping the sperm travel to the egg for fertilisation. This method can be used on its own or alongside other natural contraception methods.
  • The symptothermal method: this method combines monitoring basal body temperature with observing symptoms such as cervical mucus and other physiological signs (changes in the position and texture of the cervix, abdominal sensations like cramps or pelvic pain, as well as shifts in mood or energy). By combining several fertility indicators, women can get a fuller picture of their cycle and pinpoint their fertile periods more precisely.

It’s important to note that all these methods need proper education and training to be used effectively, and I really want to stress that. If you’re interested in natural contraception, it’s strongly recommended to see a qualified professional to learn the right techniques.

 

A note on the LAM method, or Lactational Amenorrhoea Method

This is a family-planning method that can be used during breastfeeding to avoid another pregnancy. But be careful, there are six conditions to avoid getting pregnant (you might think that as long as your period hasn’t returned there’s no risk, which is false, just as once past a certain age, if you’re not menopausal, there’s always a risk):

  1. The baby is exclusively breastfed, meaning they receive no food or liquid other than breast milk.
  2. Breastfeeding is on demand, day and night, with no gaps of more than four hours between feeds during the day and six hours at night.
  3. There has been no return of periods since the birth.
  4. Breastfeeding is the only method of contraception used.
  5. The baby is under six months old.
  6. The mother hasn’t started having periods again since the birth.

If any one of the conditions isn’t met, it’s recommended to use an additional contraceptive method to avoid an unplanned pregnancy.

the LAM method of natural contraception

How effective is natural contraception?

How effective natural contraception is varies with the method used and how carefully it’s practised. While some natural contraception methods can be effective when used correctly, it’s important to recognise that they don’t offer the same level of protection as conventional methods, such as hormonal contraceptives or intrauterine devices (IUDs). Indeed, as a 2013 study in France shows, this method has an 8% failure rate (and 25% in the United States), against 2.5% for the pill in France, and 3% in France for the male condom.

mechanical contraception, not natural

The benefits of natural contraception

Natural contraception offers several distinct benefits over conventional methods, which makes it an attractive option for many women and couples who care about their wellbeing. Here are some of the main benefits of natural contraception:

  1. Non-invasive: unlike intrauterine devices (IUDs), for example, natural contraception is non-invasive.
  2. Respectful of the body: natural contraception rests on understanding the menstrual cycle and the body’s natural signs of fertility, which lets women stay in tune with their physiology and their reproductive health.
  3. No hormonal side effects: since natural contraception doesn’t involve synthetic hormones, it doesn’t cause the hormonal side effects sometimes linked to hormonal contraceptives, such as changes in weight.
  4. Eco-friendly and economical: natural contraception produces no waste (nor the pollution found in tap water), and no recurring costs linked to buying hormonal contraceptives or contraceptive devices. That makes it an eco-friendly and economical option in the long run (it’s free!).
  5. A better connection with your cycle: by watching the signs of fertility and understanding the fluctuations of the cycle, women can strengthen their connection with their body and their cycle, which can lead to a better understanding of their reproductive health overall. A woman learns to know her body better, to tune in to her signs and her cycles. She’ll have a better grasp of her own rhythms (if you’ve ever heard of the four seasons of a cycle: a woman reconnects with her cyclical nature, something often talked about in women’s circles), of her hormonal variations, and more autonomy in managing her fertility.
  6. Better communication in the couple: as it happens, communication in the couple becomes necessary, and so is strengthened, respectfully.
communication in the couple with natural contraception

Important things to consider (the downsides)

Although natural contraception offers several benefits, it’s important to weigh up the downsides before choosing this method.

  1. Lower effectiveness, as seen above: and so either pair it with a mechanical method (condom), or abstain.
  2. It needs education and training: successfully practising natural contraception requires a good understanding of the menstrual cycle, the signs of fertility and the monitoring techniques. It’s essential that women and couples interested in this approach get proper education and training to use natural contraception methods correctly. Otherwise effectiveness drops further.
  3. Consistency and commitment: for natural contraception to be effective, you need to practise the methods consistently and track the signs of fertility carefully throughout the cycle (there are apps to help you remember and record). This can take more commitment than other contraceptive methods, and open communication between partners. You also need to be aware of, and comfortable with, handling your own secretions with your fingers. You have to take your temperature every morning at the same time, in bed, before getting up… (and know it’s not entirely reliable, for example if you have a cold).
  4. No protection against STIs: it’s important to recognise that natural contraception doesn’t protect against sexually transmitted infections (STIs). For those who are sexually active and at risk of infection, it’s recommended to combine natural contraception with the use of condoms to reduce the risk of STIs.
  5. Adapting to irregular cycles: women with irregular menstrual cycles may find it harder to practise natural contraception reliably, as it can be harder to predict the fertile periods. In such cases, it’s important to see a healthcare professional for advice on alternative contraceptive methods.

FAQ

What is natural contraception?

Natural contraception is a non-invasive, hormone-free approach to managing fertility, based on understanding your menstrual cycle and the signs of fertility. By tracking your fertile window (through basal body temperature, cervical mucus or the symptothermal method), you can choose to avoid or plan a pregnancy.

How effective is natural contraception?

It varies with the method and how carefully it’s practised. A 2013 French study puts the failure rate at around 8% (and 25% in the US), against 2.5% for the pill and 3% for the male condom in France. It’s less effective than conventional methods, so it’s often paired with a condom or abstinence during the fertile window.

Does natural contraception protect against STIs?

No. Natural contraception does not protect against sexually transmitted infections. If you’re sexually active and at risk, it’s recommended to combine it with condoms. It’s also not a substitute for medical advice, especially with irregular cycles.

What are the main methods?

The basal body temperature method (taking your temperature each morning), the Billings method (observing cervical mucus), and the symptothermal method (combining both with other signs). The LAM method can be used during exclusive breastfeeding, but only if six specific conditions are all met. All of them need proper training to use well.

I’m Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath in Paris and online, a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie and a trainer at a naturopathy school. I help people find their physical and emotional balance again through naturopathic approaches (nutrition, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants and so on).

Through this blog I share, in a down-to-earth way, the knowledge and experience I find useful, so you can feel better.

This advice is no substitute for seeing your own healthcare professional, and shouldn’t stop you doing so.

Website and search: Jigsaw Studio