A foreword: I write “natural treatments” here, but these are really “natural suggestions”, with no claim whatsoever to cure. The word “treatment” is reserved for medicine. Naturopathy “does not cure”, it supports the person’s wellbeing.
Osteoporosis increases the risk of fractures. It affects women more, once they are through the menopause. With the menopause comes the drop in oestrogen, and oestrogen helps build bone through cells called “osteoblasts”. Bone renews itself continually: it is built by these osteoblasts and broken down by the osteoclasts. Put simply and briefly: at menopause, the osteoclasts take over because of the fall in oestrogen. The bone gradually weakens (and age adds to this).
What are the natural approaches for osteoporosis and osteopenia, and what can be done in prevention? Of course, this is alongside your medical care.
The advice in this article is not a substitute for a consultation with your doctor.
Naturopathy works on your “way of life”, alongside medical care, so through diet, physical activity, and managing stress and sleep.
Before going further, we need to understand the importance of the acid-base balance in bone health. The body is always trying to keep its acid/base balance (its pH). Many things tip it towards an excess of acids: stress, not enough water, not enough exercise, not enough sleep, an acidifying diet and so on. To rebalance, the body draws on its alkaline (base, the opposite of acid) reserves, of which the bones are part. The calcium comes to “buffer” the acids.
Let’s first look at how diet can support bone health in osteoporosis.
Diet, the first natural approach for osteoporosis
The acidifying foods, to limit or avoid with osteoporosis:
- Refined sugars: white flours (white bread, white pasta or rice and so on), fizzy drinks, white sugar, chocolate too.
- Meats: red especially, and charcuterie. Fish is acidifying too, but less so. 1g of animal protein loses 1mg of calcium. However: protein is important, for bone in particular. I come back to this a little further on.
- Salt: the more you eat, the more calcium you lose. 1 gram of sodium (that is 2.5g of salt, or 5 pinches of salt) drives out 15mg of calcium.
- Alcohol.
- Coffee, beyond 2 cups a day according to one study.
- Certain vegetables and fruits are acidifying (cooked tomato, cooked spinach, citrus fruits).
- Dairy (cow, sheep or goat): it does contain calcium, but it is acidifying, cheeses in particular because of the salt. To be eaten in moderation. Did you know that the number of people affected by osteoporosis is higher in the countries that consume the most dairy?
Which foods to invite onto your plate to fight osteoporosis?
- Most vegetables, and the tubers (carrots, squash, potatoes and so on), buckwheat and quinoa. They are rich in potassium, which helps limit calcium losses. Non-acidic fruits too, like banana and sweet apples, are alkalising.
- Protein in reasonable amounts: it forms the framework of the bone on which the minerals attach. So we do need to get it from food. Favour lean meats and fish, eggs, and plant proteins. The plant ones are not to be neglected, as they are less acidifying than animal proteins. In terms of amount, count one portion of protein a day at two meals a day (to be adapted case by case). Bone broth is useful too, as it is rich in collagen, which bone is made of.
A quick aside on soya: tofu is a soya-based plant protein that contains isoflavones (phyto-oestrogens). These mimic the effects of oestrogen, which is useful after the menopause. They are said to lower bone resorption (the breaking down of bone). Best eaten lacto-fermented, several times a week, provided you have no history of hormone-dependent cancer or oestrogen sensitivity, and be careful with hypothyroidism too. Studies show that how well the oestrogens work depends on the person’s gut flora or microbiome, and that it is better to have started eating phyto-oestrogens well before the menopause: as prevention.
- The omega-3s, which help the calcium get into the bone. Being anti-inflammatory, they lower the activity of the cytokines (inflammatory molecules) involved in bone resorption. You will find them in oily fish and in organic Bleu-Blanc-Coeur eggs.
- Spring water, in quantity. A calcium-rich water does bring calcium, but over time it can tire the kidneys.
Vitamins and minerals
Many minerals and vitamins are needed to build bone. The list below is not exhaustive. Ideally, they come from food. If supplementing, I would encourage you to choose the best-absorbed forms.
– Calcium is a mineral the bone cannot do without, but it is not the only one. Calcium intake should be increased if the diet tends to be acidifying.
The main food sources of calcium are: sesame (not just as seeds, but ground or as a paste like tahini, to be absorbed), almonds, green leafy vegetables (kale, watercress, broccoli in particular), sardines with their bones, and dairy (in moderation, as it is acidifying).
Here is an example: you would get 855mg of calcium, almost 1g, by eating over the day: a tin of whole sardines (430mg of calcium per 100g) + 150g of broccoli (345mg) + 10g of sesame paste (80mg).
– Vitamin D helps absorb calcium. Sun exposure (within reason) is needed every day between April and September. Some people synthesise vitamin D less well: people with dark skin, for instance, need longer exposure. For the rest of the year, a vitamin D3 supplement is needed in mainland France because of the latitude. D3 is in fact 10 times more active than D2. Having your vitamin D level tested tells you how best to supplement.
Vitamin D can also be found in food, but often that is not enough: fish, fish oils, mushrooms, butter.
On top of that, if the vitamin D level is low, the parathyroid glands make more PTH (parathyroid hormone), which increases the action of the osteoclasts.
– Magnesium is essential for bone and for calcium metabolism: it helps calcium be absorbed, plays a part in the action of vitamin D, and supports the activity of the osteoblasts.
In food, you will find it in wholegrains, nuts and seeds, and leafy vegetables. Many people are deficient, and a supplement is often needed.
– Vitamin K is needed, as it is involved in fixing calcium onto the bone. The most active, bioavailable form is vitamin K2, found in natto, a Japanese dish. In supplements it is often paired with vitamin D for a better effect. Be careful, though, if you take anticoagulants, so check with your doctor.
– Zinc is also a constituent of bone. It stimulates the osteoblasts and plays a part in collagen synthesis. Animal proteins contain it, as do oysters and pumpkin seed oil.
– Vitamin C and vitamin B6 are also needed for collagen synthesis. Finally, a vitamin B12 deficiency (in unsupplemented vegetarians and vegans in particular) has been associated with a higher fracture risk.
Let’s now look at the second recommendation for osteoporosis.
Physical activity, in prevention and as a natural approach for osteoporosis
A sedentary life is linked to a higher risk of osteoporosis. Regular exercise helps stimulate bone production and strengthen muscle mass and bone. What matters is putting an impact through to the ground. Sport also makes you sweat, and so eliminate acids.
Running, jumping and tennis are not recommended with osteoporosis (in prevention, yes). Walking, hiking and strength training are, however. Climbing stairs too: anything that works against gravity, in fact.
Walking every day, and doing physical activity for 30 minutes 3 to 4 times a week, is recommended (of course, this depends on age and other factors).
Carrying an external load sends a signal to the bone, telling it to build more bone. You can carry these loads (10% of your body weight) at the hips, wrists or trunk, and walk like that 3 times a week for 20 minutes.
Reducing stress and sleeping enough
One of the main causes of acidosis is stress. Too high a level of stress produces more cortisol, a hormone that increases bone resorption and causes a malabsorption of calcium. Poorer oxygenation because of stress has the same consequences.
So all the good stress-management and relaxation practices are worth taking up: which one suits you, and could you put it into practice?
Let’s make an aside here about smoking (as it is often used against stress): smoking increases the risk of fractures by 15%.
Sleep, for its part, helps the body de-acidify.
Remineralising plants
Here is a list of a few plants that help prevent and address osteoporosis naturally, as they are remineralising:
- Tabashir bamboo, rich in silica: it contributes to the strength of the bone.
- Field horsetail: rich in silica too, calcium and potassium (contraindicated in kidney or heart failure, in pregnant or breastfeeding women, and with care if using diuretics).
- Nettle, very rich in minerals and trace elements, and anti-inflammatory too.
- Lithothamnion, a seaweed rich in calcium and other minerals, taken as a powder (contraindicated in kidney conditions, iodine allergy, and with care in thyroid problems).
You can take half a teaspoon a day of one of these powders with a meal, which is a simple way to work them in. Alternating them is better still.
In closing
We have seen the main pillars of the natural approach to osteoporosis and its prevention:
- An alkalising, low-salt diet, favouring vegetables and tubers, without forgetting the protein that is essential in the right amount, and including sources of calcium,
- Physical activity, walking in particular,
- Managing stress and good sleep, to eliminate the excess acidity,
- Remineralising plants that you can sprinkle onto your meals,
- The essential vitamins and minerals.
These tips are ideally to be tailored to you. It is important to understand that it is necessary to digest and absorb the foods, or the supplements, that contain them. With “leaky gut”, or low stomach acidity, the risk of osteoporosis is higher, because the needed minerals and vitamins might be poorly absorbed. Also, with an excessive intake of phytates, the minerals are trapped and cannot be used. Do feel free to speak to your naturopath if you have any doubt.
Sources:
– Dr Stéphane Résimont’s book “Vitamines D3K2”, 2020, Medicatrix editions
– The natural approach to osteoporosis. DOI: 10.11138/ccmbm/2015.12.2.111
– Coffee consumption and risk of fractures: a meta-analysis. DOI: 10.5114/aoms.2012.31612
– Intake of fruit and vegetables: implications for bone health. DOI: 10.1079/PNS2003310
– Potassium causes calcium retention in healthy adults. DOI: 10.1093/jn/123.9.1623
– Magnesium intake from food and supplements is associated with bone mineral density in healthy older white subjects. DOI: 10.1111/j.1532-5415.2005.53561.x
– Milk, dietary calcium, and bone fractures in women: a 12-year prospective study. DOI: 10.2105/ajph.87.6.992
– Thierry Souccar’s book “Lait, mensonges et propagande”, 2008, Thierry Souccar editions.
FAQ
Why does osteoporosis affect women after menopause?
Which foods help with osteoporosis?
Which vitamins and minerals matter for bone?
What exercise is best with osteoporosis?
I am Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath based in Paris and working by video call. I am a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie and I teach at a school of naturopathy. I help people find their physical and emotional balance again through naturopathic techniques (diet, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants and so on).
Through this blog I share, in a down-to-earth way, the knowledge and experience I find useful, to help you feel better.
This advice is not a substitute for seeing your own healthcare professional, and should never keep you from doing so.