The stomach is often said, even “accused”, to be too acidic. Heartburn, reflux, acid coming back up: we often conclude that we need to “calm the acidity”. And yet, in some cases, the problem is exactly the opposite: a stomach that lacks acid can lead to reflux and acidity. This is called hypochlorhydria (because we’re talking about hydrochloric acid), and it’s a common phenomenon that can disrupt the whole of digestion. Food is then less well broken down, lingers longer and can cause bloating, heaviness or paradoxical reflux. This lack of acid can also be encouraged by several factors, including a thyroid that’s working slowly (hypothyroidism). Once you understand this mechanism, it changes the way you approach the problem.
Warning: this does not in any way mean you should stop your medication, or immediately start taking vinegar to acidify.
Reflux, acidity and low stomach acid: the key points:
-
Is reflux always caused by too much acid?
No. In some people, a lack of stomach acid (also called hypochlorhydria) can slow digestion, encourage fermentation and cause reflux. So it’s important to identify the cause before trying to “neutralise” the acidity.
In short:
- Reflux isn’t always linked to too much acid, but sometimes to a lack of stomach acid
- Insufficient acidity disrupts digestion and encourages fermentation and reflux
- Stomach acid is essential for digesting, absorbing nutrients and protecting against pathogens
- Stress, deficiencies, age, medication or hypothyroidism can reduce its production
- The approach must be individualised, without trying to correct the acidity across the board
Is reflux always caused by too much acid? Or by too little?
When a feeling of heaviness appears after meals, heartburn, acidity, reflux, a lack of acid isn’t often the first thing we think of. The conclusion is almost always the same: we think we have too much acid in the stomach. This idea is very widespread, and that’s understandable, it burns! But the reality can be different.
In many digestive problems, the issue isn’t necessarily too much acid, but on the contrary an insufficient production of stomach acid. This situation has a name: hypochlorhydria.
Let me explain: when the stomach doesn’t produce enough hydrochloric acid, food is less well broken down. It can then stay longer in the stomach, ferment and produce gas. This extra pressure can encourage things coming back up towards the oesophagus.
You can then feel:
- burning,
- reflux,
- acid coming back up.
The paradox is this: these symptoms give the impression of too much acid, when they can sometimes be linked to insufficient acid and digestion that goes wrong further up the line.
Understanding this distinction matters, because stomach acid isn’t only an irritating substance, it plays an essential role in digestion running smoothly.
Why is stomach acid essential?
We often talk about stomach acid as a problem. And yet, without it, a large part of digestion can’t take place properly… and that’s easy to forget! Hydrochloric acid in fact plays several roles:
Digesting proteins
- it denatures dietary proteins to make their digestion possible
- it activates pepsin, the key enzyme that breaks proteins down into smaller peptides
Absorbing micronutrients
- it helps the absorption of iron, zinc, calcium and magnesium
- it allows vitamin B12 to be released properly from protein foods
Protection against pathogens
- it acts as a disinfecting barrier against micro-organisms swallowed with food
Regulating the digestive system
- it triggers the pancreatic secretions needed to continue digestion
- it stimulates the release of bile, essential for digesting fats in the small intestine
- The stomach doesn’t just receive food: it orchestrates the whole digestive process downstream.
Why the stomach can lack acid
The production of stomach acid depends on a set of physiological mechanisms. When one of these balances changes, acid secretion can fall and lead to hypochlorhydria (a lack of acid).
Several factors can contribute to this:
Let’s mention chronic stress, the usual suspect, which plays an important role. Digestion works best when the nervous system is in parasympathetic mode, that is, in a state of rest and safety. When stress becomes constant, the sympathetic nervous system takes over and digestive functions can be held back.
Certain nutritional deficiencies can also play a part. Producing stomach acid notably requires certain micronutrients, such as zinc or some B vitamins.
Age can also influence gastric secretion. Over time, the stomach’s ability to produce acid can gradually decline.
Some medications, in particular those that reduce stomach acidity, can also change this balance when used over long periods (see the warning in the introduction, and don’t stop this kind of medication without your doctor’s advice).
Finally, certain hormones can be involved. For example, hypothyroidism, that is, a slowing of the thyroid’s activity, can influence digestion and contribute to less effective stomach acid production.
When stomach acid is insufficient
When stomach acidity is too low, digestion can become less effective. Food is then processed more slowly, which can lead to various digestive signs.
Do the following signs ring a bell?:
- a feeling of heaviness after meals, or even a stomach that still feels full several hours after eating,
- slow digestion,
- bloating,
- reflux or acid coming back up,
- unusual tiredness after eating
- But also… a reduced absorption of certain micronutrients, such as zinc and iron, and so possible deficiencies…
These signs aren’t specific and can have several causes. But in some cases, they can be linked to insufficient stomach acid.
When proteins aren’t properly prepared in the stomach, they reach the intestine in a less well digested form. This can encourage fermentation and the production of gas.
In the long term, less effective digestion can also affect the absorption of certain nutrients. The uptake of iron, vitamin B12 or zinc, for example, can be less than optimal.
These mechanisms aren’t always visible straight away, but they remind us that stomach acid takes part in an overall digestive balance, which concerns far more than the stomach itself.
Natural tips for a lack of acid, against reflux
When facing digestive trouble, it can be tempting to look for quick fixes. And yet the question of stomach acid is complex and deserves a measured approach, because reflux can also be due to a lack of acid.
Some practices often mentioned to stimulate stomach acid, such as taking cider vinegar before meals, don’t suit everyone. Depending on the digestive context or the conditions present, they can sometimes make certain symptoms worse, or create others (if you have a histamine issue, for example). For instance, if someone feels burning because of a lack of acid, the vinegar will certainly raise the acidity but make the pain worse! In that case, repairing the stomach lining will be needed before re-acidifying.
So the approach is individualised, as always in naturopathy, and several things will be explored:
- we start at the beginning, with the way you eat, chewing, the pace of meals,
- stress management,
- nutritional balance,
- certain hormonal or micronutrient functions.
To conclude: reflux doesn’t always mean there’s too much acid. In some cases, it’s precisely the opposite. Before trying to lower or raise stomach acidity, the naturopath will seek to understand the cause. It’s this individualised approach that makes it possible to offer genuinely suitable advice.
FAQ
Is reflux always caused by too much acid?
No. While reflux is often associated with too much acid, that isn’t always the case. In some people, insufficient stomach acid production (hypochlorhydria) slows digestion. Food lingers longer, ferments and produces gas, which can encourage things coming back up towards the oesophagus. But careful, this doesn’t mean taking cider vinegar without caution before a meal!
What are the signs of a lack of stomach acid?
Hypochlorhydria can show up as a feeling of heaviness after meals, slow digestion, bloating, reflux, belching or tiredness after eating. These symptoms aren’t specific, though, and can have other causes.
Can hypothyroidism reduce stomach acid?
Yes, hypothyroidism can reduce stomach acid. A thyroid that works slowly can slow several stages of digestion, including the production of stomach acid. It’s one of the factors that can encourage hypochlorhydria.
Can a lack of stomach acid cause deficiencies?
Yes, a lack of stomach acid can cause deficiencies. Stomach acid plays an important role in absorbing several nutrients, in particular iron, vitamin B12 and zinc. Prolonged hypochlorhydria can therefore contribute, in some people, to nutritional deficits, which should be confirmed by a suitable work-up.
Is cider vinegar a good solution for reflux?
Careful! It’s often recommended on social media, that cider vinegar everyone raves about, but it doesn’t suit everyone. In some people, it can even increase pain or burning. The approach must always be individualised. And before taking any, start very gently. The stomach may need to heal first.
I’m Céline Jablonski, a certified naturopath in Paris and online, a member of the Syndicat des Professionnels de la Naturopathie, and a trainer at a naturopathy school. I help people regain physical and emotional balance through naturopathic techniques (nutrition, physical activity, stress management, the use of plants…).
Through this blog, I share, in an accessible way, knowledge and experiences I find useful, to help you feel better.
This advice is not a substitute for, and should not stop you from, consulting your healthcare professional.